Datebook: Monday, November 25th ~ 2007
At the Thanksgiving table of life, the ice-dancers will always be sitting at the kiddies’ card table in the corner. Oh, we get a tablecloth and real napkins, but the china doesn’t match, and a few of the chairs are a bit wobbly. Tanith and Ben, and the new extreme lifts, seemed to be changing that forecast a bit, but the new event coverage doesn’t bode well for pairs or ice-dancing. Case in point, Vise and Trent just had their Quad throw ratified at a Grand Prix event. Good luck finding a news source hailing this history making accomplishment.
As a journalism teacher, I am always shaking my head at the missed opportunities that writers pass when they go to the competitions. It is the standard to go to the winners and ask how they felt about their skate; but it is also so predictable. It’s like asking me if I want nuts on my hot fudge sundae.
There are so many more interesting stories out there.
Every skater at a regional or sectional competitive level has made a decision on the path his/her life will take, and it has more to do with what will be given up than what will be gained. The gains are really measured on an individual scale, and, like my weight, should not be the subject of scrutiny or comparison.
This is a sport where children move across the country, where families physically divide to support the skating enterprise, where homes are mortgaged, and where injuries come at you fast and usually on 1/8 of an inch of steel. There are a plethora of Hallmark and Lifetime movies out there, skating in circles on the ice with stories to tell.
My students tell me, “We are a society that only cares about the winners,” and I shudder to think this might be true.
I tell them, “Yes, we do care about winners, but we have not forgotten to take notice of the journey—that is the most interesting part. If we truly only cared about winners there would be no televised sporting events; there would only be scroll lines with end scores running at the bottom of television screens.”
Maybe this is the real disappointment I have with televised figure skating competitions. Those selected for airtime typically are from singles events, and plans are very rarely altered to take in the best skates of the day from pairs and ice dancing. Those two disciplines are generally never featured. Well, unless there is excessive bloodshed or loss of consciousness.
My students still bemoan the challenge of finding a good story. I tell them (and The Powers That Be--if they cared to hear my opinion) that it really isn’t that difficult; they just need to shift their focus a bit. For skating, what happens on the ice is always just going to be about having a good skate or not, on that one given day. That is the filmed version. There has to be more to the written story.
When President Kennedy died in the 60’s, thousands of journalists descended on Washington to write pieces for their papers about the mourners and the great tragedy of our nation. Jimmy Breslin, a Tribune reporter, probably epitomizes the evocative dignity of the man in his piece, “It’s An Honor” in which he interviews the gravedigger for the President’s final resting place.
I think we need to look for some real stories out there with our skaters.
And the real stories are what happened before they take their guards off, and after they put them back on.
We need to recognize that life can be fun and interesting at the kiddie table of life.
Mombo
As a journalism teacher, I am always shaking my head at the missed opportunities that writers pass when they go to the competitions. It is the standard to go to the winners and ask how they felt about their skate; but it is also so predictable. It’s like asking me if I want nuts on my hot fudge sundae.
There are so many more interesting stories out there.
Every skater at a regional or sectional competitive level has made a decision on the path his/her life will take, and it has more to do with what will be given up than what will be gained. The gains are really measured on an individual scale, and, like my weight, should not be the subject of scrutiny or comparison.
This is a sport where children move across the country, where families physically divide to support the skating enterprise, where homes are mortgaged, and where injuries come at you fast and usually on 1/8 of an inch of steel. There are a plethora of Hallmark and Lifetime movies out there, skating in circles on the ice with stories to tell.
My students tell me, “We are a society that only cares about the winners,” and I shudder to think this might be true.
I tell them, “Yes, we do care about winners, but we have not forgotten to take notice of the journey—that is the most interesting part. If we truly only cared about winners there would be no televised sporting events; there would only be scroll lines with end scores running at the bottom of television screens.”
Maybe this is the real disappointment I have with televised figure skating competitions. Those selected for airtime typically are from singles events, and plans are very rarely altered to take in the best skates of the day from pairs and ice dancing. Those two disciplines are generally never featured. Well, unless there is excessive bloodshed or loss of consciousness.
My students still bemoan the challenge of finding a good story. I tell them (and The Powers That Be--if they cared to hear my opinion) that it really isn’t that difficult; they just need to shift their focus a bit. For skating, what happens on the ice is always just going to be about having a good skate or not, on that one given day. That is the filmed version. There has to be more to the written story.
When President Kennedy died in the 60’s, thousands of journalists descended on Washington to write pieces for their papers about the mourners and the great tragedy of our nation. Jimmy Breslin, a Tribune reporter, probably epitomizes the evocative dignity of the man in his piece, “It’s An Honor” in which he interviews the gravedigger for the President’s final resting place.
I think we need to look for some real stories out there with our skaters.
And the real stories are what happened before they take their guards off, and after they put them back on.
We need to recognize that life can be fun and interesting at the kiddie table of life.
Mombo


